Tuesday, October 2, 2007

Property of Jesus.

A few days ago, the Cincinnati Enquirer (a local publication loosely referred to as a “newspaper”) ran an unusually sensible opinion piece, titled, “Congress needs to step in, make birth control more affordable.” Needless to say, the article was not written by an Enquirer staff member. Instead, a local graduate student wrote it, and she argued persuasively that via a simple fix by Congress, contraception could and should become accessible to college students and low-income women. She pointed out that until last January, birth control was relatively affordable, but costs soared as a result of the federal Deficit Reduction Act.

Seems obvious, doesn’t it, that affordable contraception is a good thing?

“No!” shouts local resident Clyde Stauffer, wearing his bathrobe and shaking his fist in his front yard:

The writer . . . set forth a position that may be expressed as follows:

Young women have a "right" to engage in unlimited sexual activity.

They have a "right" to be free from untoward consequences of such activity; therefore

Congress has an "obligation" to act so as to facilitate those "rights."

I don't believe either of her premises is correct (hence the conclusion is invalid). I don't believe the authors of the Constitution thought that one of the duties of the legislative branch is to promote untrammeled fornication. The writer's concern for an unimpeded educational outcome for these young women is commendable. She might better spend her energies on suggesting changes in their behavior to that end, rather than seeking congressional action in support of questionable activities.

Clyde clearly didn’t get any in college – and believe me, I feel his pain – but he so totally mischaracterizes the column that I wonder if he even read it. Plus, isn’t untrammeled fornication the very best kind of fornication there is?

Meanwhile, in a related story, desperate, pandering presidential candidate Sen. John McCain (remember when he seemed like an okay guy?) says Christians make the best presidents and the Constitution established the U.S. as a "Christian nation." Now, I'm not a historian or a lawyer or a Revolutionary War re-enactor, but I'm pretty sure there's no mention of Jesus in our founding documents. I'll go back and check, but I think I'm right on this one.

5 comments:

Anonymous said...

God Damn, you are awesome.

K. said...

wait, you're not a lawyer??
or a historian??

ok fine, but i don't believe that you're not into that Revolutionary War reenacting - i bet you'd look good in those redcoats with your bayonet.

and yes, it should always be "untrammeled"

Anonymous said...

That whole ounce of prevention, pound of cure thing ain't too popular among Cincinnati folk. Nothing sets us on our hackles like the thought of somebody having sex or fun.

Misplaced said...

Obviously, "The Pill" is a gateway drug. Sure at first it's all giggles and awkward fumblings at bra straps but next think you know you got a monkey on your back and bad case of meth mouth. Trust me Mr. LDP leave the sex to the politicians and the Cincninnati Enquirer- they know what they're doing.

BTW- Get involved in your local Revolutionary War Reenactment Center, it will get you more tail than Sinatra.

Karyn said...

I don't know where to comment first, here...

Trammeled can be good.

Why isn't contraception subsidized for men?

And "A Christian Nation". Seriously? SERIOUSLY. This kind of stuff makes my head throb. The constitution was written by a buncha guys sitting around under an apple tree making the broadest rules they could come up with for the world in which they lived which bears bloody little resemblance to the world we live in NOW and if we're going to go getting all "the constitution says" and "the country was founded as" , then let's first tackle the niggly little matter of the tenets and principles on which it was based NOT having been written in order to protect and accommodate those who would use it as a shield to decry, belittle and defile this nation, its inhabitants and what it stands for.

THEN we can talk about Jesus' position, role and standing in the formation of our country. (You know Jesus. That nice Jewish guy.)

Holy crap, where's my Tylenol?